foudebassan: (Default)
[personal profile] foudebassan
by Elisabeth Cleghorn Gaskell


First, I feel a bit cheated because it didn't say anywhere on the book cover that it's unfinished and who reads 700 pages of romance only to learn at page 708 that the author snuffed it before the main characters could even get engaged.

Second, and this remark is concomitant to the first, if this book were written today it would have been made to fit into 350 pages, tops, and that would have suited me better.

Apart from that, and on a slightly more intellectual note, I liked it. There is caustic humour hidden in every other sentence and a page seldom went by without a chuckle. It reminds me a LOT of Flaubert, only he hates his characters, which makes reading it unpleasant and tiresome at times, whereas she is fond of them all, even the most flawed have a good side.

I couldn't help but read it from a feminist standpoint. The women, even the smart ones, aren't educated, don't seem to travel any further than Calais, and their main concern is to look neat. Mr. Gibson loves his daughter more than anything, but he won't let her go to school or even read the classics. Instead of falling for some exterior female character Robert could have met in London with a mind to match his own, he chooses Molly who's in many ways his own creature. The only gutsy woman is Lady Cummings, and she's shown as a domestic despot - and to a lesser extend Harriet, who acts like a deus ex machina (and is conscious of being a plot device!). I doubt Gaskell meant it as a feminist pamphlet, but I certainly took it that way.

I believe her actual point was that it is meaningless to pine for the good old days of yore - pre-industrialism, pre-railroad, in a mythical golden age of agricultural happiness - since people have always been people and our lot hasn't changed much either way. Or, again, this could be me pasting my own feelings on the book.

And on a crack!ficcy note, I totally feel like writing Molly/Cynthia femslash. Molly's the only person Cynthia comes even close to loving - she only has respect for Mr. Gibson, and lots of affinities to Mr. Henderson. And Molly is far too sheltered to even think of it in these terms, but there is nothing she wouldn't do for Cynthia, which is more than she can say for anyone else bar her father. Robert is another matter - she loves him in good part precisely because he won't make demands on her.

(...and Lady Harriet could be made to fit in somehow)



Short version: I liked it, I recommend it if you have the time to spare (715 pages in the Penguin edition).

Date: 2007-11-09 12:23 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] tudorpot.livejournal.com
I have a Gaskell book here that I haven't read, I'll take a look at it now that you've shared this review- tho I will check that it is finished! You might look for a book written by Lauren Willig- a rather better written romance with a modern angle. The Secret of the Pink Carnation is the first book in the series.

Date: 2007-11-09 12:31 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] foudebassan.livejournal.com
*takes notes*

Date: 2007-11-09 12:44 am (UTC)
ext_92458: (Default)
From: [identity profile] camillo1978.livejournal.com
Hi there. Gaskille was indeed a proto-feminist. She did lots of good things to do with education in industrial revolution Manchester. Have you read North and South? Pride & Prejudice with a brain and a social consience. Utterly fab.

Date: 2007-11-09 12:33 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] foudebassan.livejournal.com
But it's like Flaubert, he's said to be feminist because his uneducated female characters are utterly stupid, but did he portray them as stupid because they're uneducated or because they're female? (to his defense, the male characters too are stupid more often than not).

I have! There's a film too, with a pretty male lead, which is actually how I discovered Gaskell.

Date: 2007-11-09 03:04 pm (UTC)
ext_92458: (Default)
From: [identity profile] camillo1978.livejournal.com
I think Gaskille had a big problem with women who chose to be ignorant, or dismissed things as "beyond them" because they were female. She thought that was crap and that women should jolly well take an interest in what the men were up to.

Date: 2007-11-09 06:14 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] foudebassan.livejournal.com
That makes sense.

Profile

foudebassan: (Default)
foudebassan

May 2017

S M T W T F S
  123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 21st, 2017 03:36 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios